Monday, April 8, 2019

Whirlwind of FLSA Activity


As previously mentioned, the DOL has been busy with the Fair Labor Standards Act and has issued a number of Opinion Letters in the past few months.  Because most of them are very fact specific, they will only be briefly summarized and readers can read their few pages in full by clicking on the links.


l  No. 2019-5: Activities of farm employees to prepare produce for the owners own farmer’s market and to deliver the produce to market can be exempt secondary agricultural activities. 


l  No. 2019-4: County Extension (i.e., 4-H) nutrition and cooking  outreach instructors (who are only required to have a GED) qualify for the exemption for teachers from overtime and minimum wages.


l  No. 2019-3: Could not determine from the facts presented whether a youth residential care facility provided enough medical care to qualify for 8 and 80 overtime system (i.e., overtime is paid when the employee works more than 8 hours in a day or 80 hours in a two week period).


l  No. 2019-2: Employers need not compensate employees for genuinely volunteering for a charity after hours even if they could receive a bonus for doing so:  The employer encouraged its employees to volunteer at sponsored events during the work day (for which they were paid) and during their free time after work.  Teams competed against each other and the winning team could win a prize.   The employer considered the number of hours that each team volunteered and was considering using an app to track employee volunteer hours.  An employer may use an employee’s time spent volunteering as a factor in calculating whether to pay the employee a bonus, without incurring an obligation to treat that time as hours worked, so as long as: 1) volunteering is optional, 2) not volunteering will have no adverse effect on the employee’s working conditions or employment prospects, and 3) the employee is not guaranteed a bonus for volunteering. The employees could select the charity or the employer’s choice.


l  No. 2019-1: Live-in building custodians are subject to the FLSA and it is not a good faith defense to rely on state-law exemptions.  But an employer may enter into reasonable agreement with individuals as to what constitutes working hours.


l  No. 2018-29: Members of religious commune who volunteer their services are not employees.


l  No. 2018-28: Employer’s compensation system complied with minimum wage requirements, but only with overtime requirements when employee’s regular rate was under $10/hour.  The employer calculated their weekly wage by multiplying the employee’s hourly rate by the number of hours the employee spent working time with clients and then divided that number by the total hours worked that week (including travel).  With this system, the employer guaranteed the employee earned above the minimum wage.   If the employee worked over 40 hours in a week, the overtime rate was calculated at the typical wage of $10/hour (even if regular rate was more than $10/hour).  That system only complied with overtime wage requirements if the employee’s regular rate was less than $10/hour. 


l  No. 2018-27: When tipped employees wear two hats and when the tip credit can be taken (i.e., if waiter is also bussing or being a janitor).


l  No. 2018-25: An employer can pay a salaried employee too much.  The employer paid its engineers a minimum $2100/week, but also paid an additional $70/hour for all hours worked over 30 each week (because their working hours varied so much throughout the year). Hours were unpredictable and some employees earned $3750 some weeks – almost twice minimum salary.  That could be too much distortion to constitute a regular salary. 150% is close to, but not necessarily, the maximum distortion.  While employers are permitted to pay salaried employees extra pay, there is still a requirement that the extra pay bear some relation to their regularity of salary. 


NOTICE: This summary is designed merely to inform and alert you of recent legal developments. It does not constitute legal advice and does not apply to any particular situation because different facts could lead to different results. Information here can be changed or amended without notice. Readers should not act upon this information without legal advice. If you have any questions about anything you have read, you should consult with or retain an employment attorney.